The "1-Minute" Review
- No 3.5mm headphone jack
- Some Android app compatibility issues
- Chrome OS only so-so on a tablet
- Heavy for a tablet
- Keyboard not firm enough for on-lap use
With Apple and Microsoft putting pressure on the high-end 2-in-1 and tablet markets, Google’s Pixel Slate looks to answer the call for a powerful Android tablet that can double as a laptop. But hitting the balance between tablet and laptop can be tricky. Let’s see if Google succeeded and what reviewers have to say about their latest release.
The aluminum chassis includes 2 USB Type-C ports, volume buttons, and a power/lock button which doubles as a fingerprint sensor.
There’s also a 4-pin connector at the bottom of the tablet (when in landscape) for accessories such as the Pixel Slate Keyboard.
Overall, reviewers loved the design and quality on offer with the Pixel Slate. They noted that it felt reassuringly hefty without being too bulky. They also liked the feel of the aluminum in the hand and complimented the design for its slim bezels and sleek lines.
Around front, you’ll find a 12.3-inch, 2000-by-3000 pixel LCD panel which Google calls a Molecular display. Reviewers loved the viewing experience on the Pixel Slate with its bold colors, excellent contrast, and mostly fluid response.
Reviewers with lower-end Celeron models had issues with the tablet keeping up during heavy multitasking or when playing high-end games.
There were also mentions of reduced contrast at extreme viewing angles. Still, in most cases, you’ll be sitting in front of the tablet to use it.
T3 says, “... the Surface Book-matching 3000x2000 panel, squashing 293 pixels per inch into its 12.3-inch area, does not disappoint even slightly. It’s vibrant without being over saturated, and absolutely razor-sharp when static.”
Powering the tablet, you’ll find a selection of 8th Generation Intel processors ranging from the basic Celeron to the productivity- and gaming-focused i7. Google paired these processors with 4 to 16GB of RAM depending on the variant you choose.
Most reviewers received the i5 model with 8GB of RAM and found it more than enough for heavy multitasking, watching streaming video, cranking out documents, or enjoying the occasional game. That said, even the i7 doesn’t compete with the iPad Pro 12.9 in benchmarks.
Reviewers with the Celeron model complained of frequent stuttering and a generally poor experience. So avoid the lowest-end options in the line up if possible.
CNet tested the i5 variant and said, “At this price, I expected buttery-smooth operations, and that's definitely not the case. It works, but that doesn't feel like enough.”
Instead of running Android, the Pixel Slate runs Chrome OS. This means you’ll need an Internet connection for some things, so be sure to have Wi-Fi nearby.
Overall, reviews of the tablet-based version of Chrome OS left reviewers with mixed opinions.
The Canadian Techie says, “Even though Google said they tried to make Chrome OS more tablet-friendly that’s not the case. Chrome OS just doesn’t work well as a tablet interface.”
T3 was more positive, saying, “There’s none of the fiddly complexity of Windows’ not-quite-properly-formed Tablet Mode, and none of the almost cartoonish simplicity sometimes displayed by iOS. Once again, this straddles the two pillars of the tablet world, and does so with aplomb.”
Depending on the model you choose, you’ll find 32 to 256GB of storage with no microSD card support. While 32GB might seem low for a “laptop replacement” keep in mind that much of Chrome OS is running in the cloud with the Chrome Browser serving as the hub offering access to a range of apps and features.
That said, you can technically upgrade storage by using an external USB storage option -- such as a flash drive, hard drive, or solid state drive. However, reviewers found drive support hit-or-miss. So you’ll want to research compatibility between the tablet and your intended drive before spending any money.
While you’re not likely to whip out your Pixel Slate to take snapshots of your dinner or a meetup with friends, you’ll find 8MP front and rear cameras available for web conferencing, video calls, and the occasional note or selfie.
Reviewers found the cameras average. This won’t replace your point-and-shoot or keep up with the cameras in Google’s Pixel phones.
TechAeris put the cameras to the test and declared “... while the front camera is fine for video chats, the rear camera is average indoors and out.”
The tablet includes a 48 watt-hour lithium-polymer battery good for roughly 10 hours of Wi-Fi surfing on a single charge. When the battery is low, you can use the USB Type-C fast charging to gain as much as 2 hours of use with a 15-minute charge.
Better still since the tablet includes 2 USB-C ports, you can still connect other accessories while charging.
Most reviewers loved the audio experience on the tablet. You’ll find two front-facing stereo speakers which many praised for the overall volume and well-balanced sound. Unfortunately, there’s no 3.5mm headphone jack. Some reviewers received USB-C to 3.5mm adaptors while others did not. So if you plan to use headphones often, be sure to check in advance if they’re included in your region.
The tablet offers two official Google accessories to help you get the most out of your tech -- the Pixelbook Pen and Pixel Slate Keyboard.
The Canadian Techie says, “The Pixelbook Pen worked really well, it’s just as smooth as the Apple Pencil and the Surface Pen.”
However, other reviewers noticed a slight delay to the input of the pen and described it as feeling sluggish or syrupy. If you’re looking for a tablet for professional graphics work or digital art, Apple’s iPad Pro 12.9 (2018) might be a better option.
The Pixel Slate Keyboard saw similarly mixed reviews. While the round buttons offered plenty of travel and the backlight was great for dimmer environments, many found the base of the keyboard too flimsy for use anywhere but on a table. More concerning, some reviewers had issues with the keyboard disconnecting from the tablet.
Fortunately, with USB-C and Bluetooth, you can hook up your favorite keyboard and mouse without issues -- but these are often less portable than a good keyboard cover would be.
Overall, the Pixel Slate confused reviewers. The price puts it in direct competition with the high-end options from Microsoft and Apple while the experience just doesn’t match. You’ll also likely need to pick up at least a keyboard to make the most of using it. This adds further to an already questionable price.
T3 says, “It’s a Chromebook in a tablet form factor, turbocharged and spiced up, something for work and for play, but not necessarily something which is going to replace either a dedicated tablet or a full-blown PC.”
However, CNet sums up most concerns best, saying, “This is the type of product I want future Chromebooks to be, but not at this price… the Pixel Slate is attempt (sic) at pushing a luxury price on a device that doesn't feel like it earns it.”