Skip to content
Home…›Industry
Rumor

Pre-paid plans break patent law

Summary (AI)

Can you imagine if somebody patented pre-paid plans? That’s what happening south of the 49th. Over the past several months Boston Communications Group Inc. (BCGI), which carries out the pre-paid plans for Verizon, Cingular, and Sprint (formerly Nextel), has been fighting a legal battle over their implementation of pre-paid plans and the $128 million dollar award levied against them. It turned out that Freedom Wireless owned the type of pre-paid plan offered through BCGI. In May of this year, a district judge ruled that BCGI had infringed on two patents owned by Freedom and ordered the defendants to pay $128 million. Last week, the court further ordered BCGI to pay $20 million in interest on lost royalties. If things couldn’t get any worse, last week an injunction against BCGI stops them from selling their services. Cingular Wireless and AT&T Wireless were named co-defendants while Verizon, in hindsight, did the right thing and settled out of court. 70% of BCGI’s business comes from Cingular. I really don’t know the particulars around Freedom Wireless’ pre-paid plans, but it seems to me that the idea of pre-paying for services or products is not new. Isn’t that what we get when we buy a gift certificate? You buy a card for a preset amount and it’s redeemed for products or services until the value of the card is 0. So, how can you patent that? BCGI has asked the court to stay the injunction while it files for an appeal (and probably uses the time to figure a way out of this financial mess). I’ve also heard that Freedom Wireless has 4 employees and never implemented the idea, nor could I find any corporate website or information. So, that leads me to the reason for writing this post: why should I do any work at all? Me and my buddies sit around and dream up weird business ideas all the time, but we’re too lazy to do anything about them. We should just patent good, bad, and obvious ideas that haven’t already been patented and wait for someone industrious enough to carry it out. Then, we sue them out of business. If Freedom Wireless can do it, why can’t we?

Community

Comments

Leave a comment